US Crypto Asset Exchange Business Multi-Layer Licensing System

1. System Overview

The United States operates a federal + 50 -state multi-layer regulatory structure and runs the world’s most complex crypto asset licensing regime. VASP (Virtual Asset Service Provider) operators must obtain a combination of the following:

• (a) Federal FinCEN MSB registration — Mandatory AML/CFT foundation
• (b) State MTL (Money Transmitter License) or OCC Federal Trust Charter — Remittance and custody operations
• (c) NY BitLicense when operating in New York State — A strict regime imposed solely by the NY Department of Financial Services
• (d) Separate SEC / CFTC regulation — Further branching based on securities or derivatives classification

2. 4 License Hierarchy

• FinCEN MSB: Federal Money Services Business registration. AML/CFT reporting obligations. The foundational layer required by all VASPs
• State MTL: Obtained separately in each of 50 states. Required by most states; up to 50 licenses needed for nationwide operations. Net worth / bond / reporting standards vary by state
• NY BitLicense: 2015-06 NY DFS regime. Regarded as the industry’s strictest; approximately 30 社 holders (Coinbase / Gemini / bitFlyer USA / Circle, etc.). Kraken withdrew
• OCC Federal Trust Charter: Federal trust bank authorisation. Anchorage Digital obtained the first US charter in 2021-01 . Can exempt 50 state MTLs; the core license for institutional custody

3. SEC vs CFTC Jurisdictional Competition

If a token is determined to be a “security,” it falls under SEC jurisdiction (Howey test standard); if classified as a “commodity,” it falls under CFTC jurisdiction (BTC / ETH being representative examples). The lack of clear determination persisted for years, but the CLARITY Act / FIT21 (passed by the House in 2024 年) seeks to clarify the bifurcation. Where recognised as a securities exchange, ATS registration or a broker-dealer license is also required.

4. Major Operator License Combinations

• Coinbase (Nasdaq: COIN) — BitLicense + multiple state MTLs + SEC-registered broker
• Kraken — State MTLs + FinCEN MSB · No BitLicense (withdrew from NY)
• Gemini — BitLicense + NY Trust Charter
• Anchorage Digital — OCC Federal Trust Charter (first in US)
• Circle — State MTLs + FinCEN MSB + 2025 年 OCC Trust Charter (USDC issuer)

5. International Comparison

Unlike Japan’s FSA / JVCEA (single federal supervisor) or South Korea’s FSC / FIU (single supervisor), the US federal + state dual-oversight structure is the world’s most complex. Regulatory compliance costs for nationwide operations reach tens of millions of dollars, resulting in ecosystem concentration among a small number of major operators. This “fragmented” model contrasts sharply with integrated frameworks such as Hong Kong’s SFC and the EU’s MiCA.

---

Cross-links

• global-cex-top10-comparison — Global comparison including Coinbase / Kraken
• global-institutional-custody-five-pillars — Anchorage OCC Trust positioning
• fsa-vasp-registration-system — Japan system comparison
• korea-cex-five-pillars-comparison — South Korea system comparison
• hk-sfc-vasp-licensing-overview — Hong Kong system comparison
• cftc-sec-crypto-jurisdiction — SEC/CFTC jurisdictional competition details
• occ-trust-bank-charter-federal-stablecoin-arbitrage — OCC Trust federal arbitrage structure
• global-vasp-regulatory-comparison-matrix — Global VASP regulatory comparison matrix
• global-stablecoin-regulatory-five-pole-matrix — Global stablecoin regulatory 5 -pole comparison
• eu-mica-casp-regime-overview — EU MiCA CASP regime comparison